Employee, Contractor or Labour Hire? Getting the Engagement Model Right in Australia

    STASX EditorialOct 27, 20267 min read

    IT Hiring and Staffing

    The law looks at how a working relationship really operates, not just what the contract says. What that means for employers and clients.

    Whether a person is an employee, an independent contractor or a labour hire worker affects pay, leave, tax, superannuation, insurance and legal risk. Getting it wrong can lead to back pay, penalties and reputational damage.

    The rules have moved in recent years, particularly since the Fair Work Act changes known as Closing Loopholes. This article is general information, not legal advice, so take specific advice for your own arrangements.

    Why the label is not enough

    Many businesses assume that a signed contractor agreement settles the question. It does not. Since 26 August 2024 the Fair Work Act asks whether the relationship is, in substance, one of employment, by looking at the whole arrangement, including how it works in practice. Factors include:

    • How much control the business has over how, when and where the work is done
    • Whether the person is part of the business or runs their own
    • Whether they can delegate the work or hire others
    • Whether they work for several clients and market their services
    • Who provides the tools and equipment, and who carries the commercial risk
    • Whether they are paid for results or for time

    If the real relationship is employment, the person is an employee whatever the document says.

    The three common arrangements

    Employee

    The employer pays wages, superannuation and payroll taxes where they apply, provides leave and other entitlements under the National Employment Standards and any award, and carries workers compensation and safety duties. This suits ongoing roles that are part of the business.

    Independent contractor

    A genuine contractor runs their own business, usually has an ABN, sets how the work is done, invoices for the work and manages their own tax, insurance and super. This suits defined projects or specialist skills. Be aware of two points. First, under the superannuation guarantee law, a contractor who is paid mainly for their labour can be treated as an employee for super purposes. Second, pretending an employee is a contractor can amount to sham contracting, which carries significant penalties.

    Labour hire and staffing arrangements

    A labour hire or staffing provider employs or engages the worker and places them with a host business. The host directs the daily work, the provider handles employment obligations. This is the model behind most staff augmentation. It can be a good way to add capacity quickly, but it is also where the rules have tightened most.

    What has changed for labour hire

    • Same job, same pay. Since November 2024 the Fair Work Commission can make an order that requires labour hire workers to be paid no less than they would receive under the host's enterprise agreement for the same work. Hosts covered by an enterprise agreement should be aware of this.
    • State licensing. Queensland, Victoria, South Australia and the ACT require labour hire providers to hold a licence. If you use a provider, check that they are licensed where required.
    • Payroll tax. States and territories have rules about how payroll tax applies to contractors and labour hire arrangements. They differ, so check the position where you operate.

    Questions to ask a provider

    1. Who is the legal employer of the person, and which award or agreement applies to them?
    2. Do you hold any labour hire licence that is required in the state?
    3. How do you meet superannuation, payroll tax and workers compensation obligations?
    4. How do you confirm work rights and run background checks?
    5. What insurance do you carry, and what do you ask contractors to carry?
    6. What are the notice and replacement terms?

    Questions to ask yourself as the client

    • Would this person do the same work, in the same way, as one of our employees? If so, treat the arrangement with care.
    • Have we kept the same person for a long time with no end date? Long open ended arrangements invite questions.
    • Do we control hours and methods in a way that suggests employment?
    • Is the real aim to save on entitlements? That is the wrong reason, and the law is designed to catch it.

    Good practice

    Choose the model that matches the real nature of the work. Use employees for core, ongoing roles. Use genuine contractors for defined, specialist projects. Use a reputable labour hire or staffing partner when you need capacity fast and want someone else to carry the employment obligations. Keep written agreements that describe the arrangement honestly, and review long running engagements regularly.

    The Fair Work Ombudsman has clear guidance and an online tool to help decide whether a worker is an employee or a contractor. If you are unsure, talk to us and take legal advice before you commit.

    Further reading

    fairwork.gov.au
    • Labour Hire
    • Independent Contractors
    • Fair Work Act
    • Sham Contracting

    Share this article

    Have a question about this topic?

    Talk to the engineers behind the research.

    (+61) 406 267 743